UCF Beats BYU 39-31 in Double OT Thriller

Cougars vs Knights — Beatline Sports preview

The UCF Knights (4-3) upset the No. 2 BYU Cougars (6-1) with a 39-31 double-overtime victory on October 24, sending BYU down six spots to No. 8 in the AP Poll.

The UCF Knights secured a dramatic 39-31 victory over the visiting BYU Cougars on Saturday, October 24, in a game that extended into double overtime. The win snapped BYU’s undefeated streak and marked a significant turning point in the Big 12 standings, while propelling UCF into contention as they improved their record to 4-3.

UCF Knights Performance

UCF quarterback Keyone Jenkins delivered a clutch performance, completing 25 of 41 passes for 293 yards and three touchdowns. Jenkins proved to be the difference-maker in the extra periods, connecting with tight end Grayson Brousseau for the game-winning 2-yard touchdown pass in the second overtime. He also contributed on the ground with a 1-yard rushing touchdown during regulation.

The Knights’ offensive attack was balanced by running back Duke Watson, who controlled the clock with 15 carries for 94 yards. Wide receiver Tyren Hornes provided a critical downfield threat, hauling in six receptions for 137 yards. Defensively, Ken Talley applied necessary pressure with one sack, and linebacker Jayden Williams anchored the unit with eight total tackles. The scoring sequence included Landen Chambers catching a 6-yard pass from Jenkins and Sione Moa punching it in from the 1-yard line to help secure the lead before overtime.

BYU Cougars Performance

Despite the loss, BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier posted strong individual numbers, completing 16 of 32 passes for 257 yards and two touchdowns, though he did throw one interception. Bachmeier also rushed for a 1-yard touchdown, keeping the Cougars in the hunt throughout the contest. Receiver Kyler Kasper led the receiving corps with six catches for 129 yards and one touchdown, including a 27-yard strike from Bachmeier early in the game.

On the ground, Preston Rex contributed five carries for 42 yards. The BYU defense was led by linebacker Cade Uluave, who recorded a team-high 10 total tackles, and defensive lineman Justin Kirkland, who added one sack. Head coach Kalani Sitake disputed a roughing-the-kicker penalty call in the second overtime but acknowledged that UCF “bested us” on the day. The Cougars remained competitive until the final whistle, but defensive vulnerabilities allowed UCF to score 39 points.

Turning Point: Double Overtime Drama

The game reached its climax in the second overtime period. After both teams exchanged possessions, UCF capitalized on a controversial roughing-the-kicker penalty against BYU. This infraction set up Jenkins’ game-winning 2-yard touchdown pass to Grayson Brousseau. While Sitake argued the call, the outcome stood, giving UCF the 39-31 win. The late scoring, including Will Stone’s field goals and Matthias Dunn’s kickoffs, highlighted the high stakes and intensity of the matchup.

Key Takeaways from the Matchup

  • UCF’s Keyone Jenkins threw for 293 yards and 3 TDs, leading the Knights to their first major upset of the season.
  • BYU’s Bear Bachmeier threw for 257 yards and 2 TDs but could not overcome the defensive lapse in double overtime.
  • The loss caused BYU to plummet six spots in the AP Poll, dropping them from No. 2 to No. 8.
  • UCF improves to 4-3 and remains in the thick of the Big 12 race, while BYU stays second in the conference at 6-1.

What It Means Next

For UCF, the victory solidifies their place in the Big 12 standings. They return to action on Saturday, October 30, when they host the Baylor Bears (4-3) at home. Both teams enter that pivotal collision with identical records, making it a crucial test for postseason positioning. For BYU, the focus shifts to regaining momentum. The Cougars face the Arizona State Sun Devils (4-3) at LaVell Edwards Stadium on Saturday, October 31. As they look to climb back into the national spotlight, every remaining conference game carries heightened importance for their College Football Playoff resume.

🎧 Listen daily to both teams

Beatline Sports covers every team, every day — new episodes each morning.

Enjoying the show? Help keep every episode free.☕ Support Beatline